Shallots vs Onions: What’s the Difference?
Shallots and onions are closely related vegetables, but they differ in their typical flavour, size and growing habit. Shallots often have a delicate, slightly sweet flavour, while ordinary cooking onions usually provide larger bulbs and a stronger onion taste.
Keter Manor Outdoor Apex Double Door Garden Storage Shed (6 x 8ft)
A durable and stylish beige and brown garden storage shed perfect for storing garden tools, equipment, bikes, and outdoor essentials. Weather-resistant, low maintenance, and ideal for any garden or allotment setup.
👉 VIEW THE AMAZON DEALFor gardeners, the most useful distinction is how they grow. A traditional shallot set can produce a cluster of bulbs, whereas an ordinary onion set generally produces one main bulb. Shallots grown from seed normally produce one bulb per seedling, so check what you are buying before planting.
Both crops deserve a place in a productive kitchen garden. This guide explains their differences, how to choose between them and when you can substitute one for the other.
Shallots vs Onions at a Glance
| Feature | Shallots | Ordinary bulb onions |
|---|---|---|
| Typical size | Usually smaller, although elongated varieties can be substantial | Often larger, with considerable variation |
| Shape | Rounded, oval or elongated | Commonly round or flattened |
| Flavour | Often delicate and slightly sweet; raw bulbs can still be pungent | Varies from mild and sweet to strongly pungent |
| Growth from sets | Traditional multiplying types form clusters | Usually one main bulb per set |
| Growth from seed | Normally one bulb per seedling | Normally one bulb per seedling |
| Common kitchen uses | Dressings, sauces, roasting and pickling | Soups, stews, curries, roasting and general cooking |
| Storage | Depends on variety, maturity and drying | Depends on variety, maturity and drying |
These are general differences. Variety, growing conditions and cooking method all affect the finished crop.
What Are Shallots?
Shallots are members of the allium family and are closely related to ordinary onions. Traditional multiplying shallots belong to the Allium cepa Aggregatum Group.
Their papery skins may be golden, copper-coloured, reddish or grey. Inside, the flesh can be pale or tinged with pink and purple.
Small rounded shallots are familiar, but elongated varieties are also widely available. These longer bulbs are often sold as banana shallots or echalions.
Are Shallots Just Small Onions?
A small onion is not automatically a shallot.
Ordinary onions may remain small because of their variety, close spacing or difficult growing conditions. Shallots are sold as particular varieties with their own characteristics.
Size alone is therefore a poor way to identify them. Check the variety name and description, especially when buying planting material.
What Are Ordinary Bulb Onions?
Ordinary bulb onions are grown for their swollen bulbs, which consist of fleshy layers beneath a dry outer skin.
Common types include brown or yellow onions, red onions and white onions. Within these groups, varieties differ in flavour, size, harvest time and storage performance.
Colour does not reliably tell you how mild an onion will taste. Some red onions are quite pungent, while some pale onions are relatively sweet.
Choose varieties for the result you want, whether that is small pickling onions, dependable storage bulbs or large onions for cooking.
How Do Shallots and Onions Taste Different?
Shallots often give a gentler onion flavour, making them useful when finely chopped into dressings or cooked in sauces.
Ordinary brown onions usually provide a fuller onion flavour and are convenient when a recipe needs a substantial quantity.
However, shallots are not always mild. A freshly cut raw shallot can be sharp, and an onion cooked slowly can become soft and sweet.
What Happens When You Cook Them?
Both shallots and onions soften and develop sweetness as they cook.
Finely chopped shallots cook quickly, so watch them carefully when frying. They can catch and become bitter if the heat is too high.
Onions are useful for building the base of a dish. A larger bulb provides plenty of chopped onion without the extra peeling involved in preparing several small shallots.
For roasting, either can work well. Keep pieces a similar size so they cook evenly.
How Do They Grow Differently?
The distinction between sets and seeds matters more than many gardeners expect.
A set is a small bulb planted to grow on. A seed produces a seedling, which then develops into a mature plant.
Traditional Shallot Sets
A traditional multiplying shallot set develops into a group of bulbs around its planting position.
The final number and size depend on the variety and growing conditions. Avoid relying on a guaranteed number of bulbs from every set.
Give multiplying shallots enough room for the cluster to develop. Crowding them can leave you with smaller bulbs.
Onion Sets
An ordinary bulb onion set generally develops into one larger onion.
Planting one onion set does not usually produce a cluster of separate onions. Multiplying onions exist, but they should be identified as such when purchased.
Shallots and Onions from Seed
Seed-grown shallots normally produce one bulb per seedling, as do ordinary bulb onions.
If several seedlings are grown together in a module, they can produce a group of neighbouring bulbs. That group comes from several plants, rather than one planted bulb dividing.
Check whether your shallots are supplied as multiplying sets, seeds or young plants so you know what harvest to expect.
Are Banana Shallots Different?
Banana shallots are elongated shallots commonly used in cooking. Their larger, longer shape can make them quicker to peel and slice than small rounded shallots.
The name describes their appearance, but it does not guarantee how they will multiply in the garden.
When buying banana shallot seeds or sets, read the growing information for that particular variety. Do not assume every elongated shallot will form a cluster.
Which Is Easier to Grow in the UK?
Both are approachable crops, particularly when started from sets.
Their success depends on similar basics: a sunny position, suitable planting material, good drainage and control of competing weeds.
The main practical difference is allowing space for multiplying shallots to spread.
Choosing a Planting Time
Spring is a common planting season for both crops. Some varieties are suitable for autumn planting, but the packet or supplier should specifically identify them for that purpose.
Autumn planting is less suitable where soil stays waterlogged through winter. Waiting until spring can give a better result than planting into persistently wet ground.
Do not plant solely by a traditional calendar date. Check the variety instructions and the condition of your soil.
Choosing a Growing Position
An open, sunny bed helps both crops grow well.
Avoid compacted ground where water collects. Raised beds can help on heavier soil, provided excess water can drain away.
Prepare the bed before planting and remove perennial weeds. Keep the developing crop clear of competition, taking care when working close to shallow roots.
Can You Grow Shallots and Onions in Containers?
Both can grow in containers, although limited space restricts the harvest.
Choose a container with drainage holes and enough depth for healthy roots. Use a suitable peat-free growing medium and leave adequate space between plants.
Multiplying shallots need room for their developing clusters. Packing in extra sets may produce more plants but smaller individual bulbs.
Container crops need closer attention to watering because their growing medium dries out faster than garden soil. Keep moisture reasonably consistent during active growth without leaving the container waterlogged.
For a substantial supply of cooking onions, a garden bed is generally more practical than a small pot.
Can You Substitute Shallots for Onions?
You can substitute them in many everyday recipes, especially soups, stews and other cooked dishes.
The flavour may change slightly, but the result is often perfectly usable.
Replacing Shallots with Onion
Use a suitable amount of finely chopped onion, allowing for the fact that an onion may be much larger than a shallot.
Start with a modest quantity in raw dressings or delicate sauces, where a stronger onion flavour will be more noticeable.
Replacing Onion with Shallots
Shallots can replace onion in many cooked dishes, although you may need to peel several to provide the same quantity.
They are particularly convenient when a recipe only needs a small amount.
Why There Is No Exact Substitution Ratio
Bulb sizes vary too much for a fixed rule such as “one onion equals three shallots” to work consistently.
Match the approximate prepared weight or chopped volume instead. Then adjust to suit the dish and your taste.
Which Is Better for Pickling?
Both shallots and small onions can be used for pickling.
Shallots are a familiar choice, while onions sold specifically for pickling offer small bulbs suited to the job.
Choose firm, sound bulbs and follow a reliable pickling recipe. Using bulbs of a similar size helps produce a more even texture.
Large banana shallots are less convenient when you want small whole pickles, although they can be used in recipes that call for sliced shallots.
Which Stores Better?
There is no universal winner.
Storage depends on the variety, whether the bulbs matured properly, how thoroughly they were dried and whether they suffered damage or disease.
A well-grown storage onion can keep better than a poorly dried shallot. Equally, a suitable shallot variety can store well when harvested and cured carefully.
Allow mature bulbs to dry in a sheltered, airy place. Store sound bulbs somewhere cool, dry and ventilated, and inspect them regularly.
Set aside damaged bulbs or those that produced flower stalks for earlier use. Do not mix soft or rotting bulbs into the stored crop.
Should You Grow Shallots or Onions?
Choose onions if you want larger bulbs for frequent everyday cooking. They are useful when preparing meals that need a generous quantity of chopped onion.
Choose shallots if you enjoy their flavour, want smaller portions or like growing traditional multiplying varieties.
Growing a modest quantity of each is a useful starting point. You can compare how they perform in your soil and see which crop you use most often.
If space is limited, grow what earns its place in your kitchen rather than choosing solely by bulb size or the number produced.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Shallots the Same as Red Onions?
No. Some shallots have reddish skins, but red onions are a separate choice of ordinary bulb onion. Similar colouring does not make them interchangeable varieties.
Do All Shallots Multiply?
No. Traditional multiplying shallot sets form clusters, while shallots grown from seed normally produce one bulb per seedling.
Can You Grow Shallots and Onions Together?
Yes. They need similar growing conditions. Allow suitable spacing for each and remember that they share several pests and diseases.
Are Shallots Always Sweeter Than Onions?
No. Shallots often have a delicate, sweet flavour, but varieties differ. Preparation and cooking also make a considerable difference.
Why Did My Onion Produce Two Bulbs?
Occasional splitting or doubling can happen. It does not mean an ordinary onion variety will reliably behave like a multiplying shallot.
Which Should Beginners Try First?
Either can be a good starting crop when grown from healthy sets. Choose a variety suited to your planting season, prepare a sunny, well-drained bed and keep weeds under control.
Keep smiling, keep shining, keep gardening with Ben.
📘 Learn How to Grow Your Own Fruit & Vegetables
Growing your own veg is one of the most rewarding things you can do on an
allotment or in the garden — saving money, eating better, and enjoying the
process from seed to harvest.
Allotment Month By Month: Grow your Own Fruit and Vegetables,
know exactly what to do and when, with clear month-by-month guidance that
makes growing easier and more successful.
👉
Take a look at this book on Amazon