Hydrangea Annabelle vs Incrediball: What’s the Difference?
The main difference between Hydrangea ‘Annabelle’ and Incrediball is stem strength. Incrediball was selected as an improvement on ‘Annabelle’, combining large white flower heads with stronger, more upright stems.
Keter Manor Outdoor Apex Double Door Garden Storage Shed (6 x 8ft)
A durable and stylish beige and brown garden storage shed perfect for storing garden tools, equipment, bikes, and outdoor essentials. Weather-resistant, low maintenance, and ideal for any garden or allotment setup.
👉 VIEW THE AMAZON DEALBoth are smooth hydrangeas, Hydrangea arborescens, and both flower on new growth produced during the current season. Their basic care requirements are therefore similar.
Choose Incrediball if keeping large flowers upright is your main priority. Choose ‘Annabelle’ if you enjoy its softer, arching appearance and are happy to provide support where needed.
Annabelle vs Incrediball at a Glance
| Feature | Annabelle | Incrediball |
|---|---|---|
| Botanical identity | Hydrangea arborescens ‘Annabelle’ | Hydrangea arborescens ‘Abetwo’, sold as Incrediball or Strong Annabelle |
| Main attraction | Large white flower heads and a relaxed habit | Large white flower heads on stronger stems |
| Stem strength | More prone to bending beneath heavy flowers | Selected for improved strength and upright growth |
| Flower colour | Greenish when developing, white at its main display, then ageing greenish | Similar green-to-white-to-green progression |
| Flowering wood | Current season’s growth | Current season’s growth |
| Pruning season | Late winter or early spring | Late winter or early spring |
| Preferred soil | Moist but well drained | Moist but well drained |
| Main consideration | May need support | Stronger stems do not remove the need for suitable growing conditions |
Neither plant is guaranteed to remain perfectly upright in every garden or storm.
Are Incrediball and Strong Annabelle the Same Plant?
For the original white-flowered selection, yes.
Incrediball and Strong Annabelle are names used for Hydrangea arborescens ‘Abetwo’.
The cultivar name is useful when comparing nursery labels because retail naming can vary.
However, other plants with similar names are different selections. Incrediball Blush, for example, is not the original white-flowered ‘Abetwo’.
Check the full label rather than assuming everything sold with “Annabelle” or “Incrediball” in its name is identical.
Which Has Bigger Flowers?
Both can produce substantial rounded flower heads.
Incrediball is promoted for particularly large heads, but actual size depends on plant maturity, pruning, water availability and growing conditions.
A well-grown ‘Annabelle’ can also produce impressively large flowers.
Avoid choosing solely by the largest measurement in a catalogue. That figure may describe an exceptional head rather than the average display in your garden.
The relationship between flower size and stem strength is often more useful than size alone.
Which Is Less Likely to Flop?
Incrediball is the stronger choice if flopping is your main concern.
Its improved stem strength is the central difference from ‘Annabelle’. This helps support the flower heads, particularly when rain adds weight.
However, growing conditions still matter.
Deep shade, weak establishment and overly lush growth can affect the framework. Severe wind and rain can also damage otherwise healthy stems.
‘Annabelle’ often benefits from support fitted early, before the flowers become heavy.
Can Pruning Stop Annabelle Flopping?
Pruning influences the shape and strength of the display, but it does not guarantee upright flowers.
Very hard pruning can encourage large heads on vigorous new shoots. Those heads can become heavy when wet.
Retaining a suitable framework rather than cutting every stem to ground level may help provide support.
Use a method suited to the plant’s condition and the display you want. Early support is often easier than trying to lift collapsed stems later.
Do They Flower at the Same Time?
Both are summer-flowering shrubs.
The exact timing varies with weather, location, pruning and establishment. A recently planted shrub may also perform differently from a mature specimen.
Do not assume one will always flower a set number of weeks before the other.
Their main comparison is flower presentation and stem strength rather than a completely different flowering season.
How Big Do They Grow?
Both develop into substantial shrubs rather than permanently compact bedding plants.
Final height and spread depend on pruning and growing conditions, and published dimensions vary.
Check the supplier’s mature-size guidance and leave room around the plant. Do not base spacing solely on the small nursery pot.
For a narrow border, consider whether either has enough space to develop without repeated trimming during the growing season.
Do They Need Different Growing Conditions?
Their basic requirements are similar.
Provide suitable light, fertile soil and consistent moisture without prolonged saturation.
A bright position with some shelter is useful. Partial shade can work, while sunnier conditions require particular attention to moisture.
Deep shade is less suitable if you want a strong flowering display.
Avoid planting directly into a dry, heavily root-competed area beneath established trees without assessing whether the shrub can obtain enough water.
Which Is Better for a Sunny Border?
Either can work where moisture is adequate and exposure is suitable.
A hot, dry position can stress both plants, especially during establishment.
Check the root ball during dry spells rather than assuming surrounding soil moisture is sufficient.
Incrediball’s stronger stems do not make it a drought-proof alternative to ‘Annabelle’.
Choose the site first, then select the plant for the form and display you prefer.
Which Is Better in Partial Shade?
Both can be suitable for a reasonably bright, partially shaded border.
However, “partial shade” should not be confused with a dark position receiving little useful growing-season light.
If flowering is poor or stems become weak, review the actual light and moisture conditions before assuming the variety is at fault.
A more expensive cultivar cannot compensate for a fundamentally unsuitable site.
How Should You Prune Them?
Both flower on new wood, so their pruning differs from that of many traditional mophead hydrangeas.
Late winter or early spring is the usual period for structural pruning.
Remove dead or damaged growth and shorten stems according to the plant’s condition and your preferred framework.
Hard cutting is possible, but it is not compulsory every year.
Avoid repeatedly trimming new shoots through late spring and summer, because these are the shoots that develop the flowers.
Do You Need to Change the Soil Acidity?
Neither plant needs a hydrangea colourant to produce its white display.
The familiar relationship between soil conditions and pink or blue flowers applies to other hydrangea groups.
‘Annabelle’ and the original white Incrediball will not become blue because you add a colour-changing treatment.
Focus on soil structure, appropriate nutrition and moisture rather than attempting to alter their flower colour.
Can You Grow Either in a Pot?
It is possible, but both need enough root space and attentive care.
A small decorative container is unlikely to provide a satisfactory long-term home.
Use a suitably sized draining pot and appropriate growing medium. Check moisture regularly, particularly once the shrub is carrying a large leaf canopy.
Container roots are more exposed to winter conditions, so review shelter and root protection where needed.
Neither should be chosen as a permanently small plant merely because it is being grown in a pot.
Should You Replace Annabelle With Incrediball?
Not automatically.
If your ‘Annabelle’ flowers well and suits the border, support and thoughtful care may be all it needs.
Incrediball is worth considering when choosing a new plant and stronger stems are important to you.
Before replacing an existing shrub, check whether flopping is being worsened by deep shade, unsuitable pruning, poor establishment or exposure.
Changing the cultivar without correcting those conditions may not deliver the improvement you expect.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Annabelle If:
- You like a softer, more relaxed display.
- You are happy to fit discreet supports.
- You already have a healthy plant that performs well.
- Large white flowers matter more than a rigidly upright shape.
Choose Incrediball If:
- Stronger stems are a priority.
- You want a more upright presentation of large flower heads.
- You are planting a new border and have suitable space.
- You want the original white ‘Abetwo’ selection rather than a different similarly named plant.
Both need appropriate planting and aftercare to perform well.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Incrediball Just Another Name for Annabelle?
No. They are different cultivars of the same species. Incrediball refers to ‘Abetwo’, which is also sold as Strong Annabelle.
Is Incrediball Completely Flop-Proof?
Its stems are stronger, but no shrub is immune to unsuitable conditions or severe weather.
Can They Be Pruned the Same Way?
Their new-wood flowering habit means the same general pruning season applies. Adjust the severity to the plant and desired framework.
Will Annabelle Turn Into Incrediball With Different Feeding?
No. Feeding does not change one cultivar into another.
Which Is Best for a UK Garden?
Choose according to space, site and the display you prefer. Incrediball offers improved stem strength, while ‘Annabelle’ remains an attractive option with suitable support.
The main decision is straightforward: ‘Annabelle’ provides the familiar generous white display, while Incrediball offers a similar effect with stronger stems. Give either the right conditions before expecting its best performance.
Keep smiling, keep shining, keep gardening with Ben.
📘 Learn How to Grow Your Own Fruit & Vegetables
Growing your own veg is one of the most rewarding things you can do on an
allotment or in the garden — saving money, eating better, and enjoying the
process from seed to harvest.
Allotment Month By Month: Grow your Own Fruit and Vegetables,
know exactly what to do and when, with clear month-by-month guidance that
makes growing easier and more successful.
👉
Take a look at this book on Amazon